A small dark skipper perched on the ground or on a low twig on a hilltop in spring, brown-black with a gray patch on the forewing, is likely a duskywing, and in lupine country it may be the Persius duskywing. Erynnis persius flies early, once a year, and the eastern form has become a conservation concern. BAMONA’s range entry covers a lot of ground: in the west from Alaska and the McKenzie River delta south to southeastern Manitoba, then south through the western mountains to southern California, southern Arizona and southeast New Mexico, and in the east from northern New England west to Wisconsin and south in the Appalachians to Virginia.
Identification, and why it is hard
BAMONA describes the upperside as brown-black. The forewing has few clear dots and very dim markings, with a grayish patch at the end of the cell. The male forewing has many raised white hairs, a costal fold holds yellow scent scales, and the hindwing fringes are dark. The female has a patch of scent scales on the seventh abdominal segment. Wingspan is 1 1/8 to 1 5/8 inches (2.9 to 4.2 cm) in BAMONA; Animal Diversity Web gives 29 to 42 mm.
The honest difficulty is in the comments line: the Columbine, Wild Indigo and Persius duskywings belong to the “Persius complex,” a confusing group of very similar butterflies. Wikipedia likewise says the species may be difficult to distinguish from other duskywing skippers, and Animal Diversity Web advises care where ranges overlap. Locality, date and host plant carry more weight than wing pattern in the field.
Habitat and behavior
BAMONA lists open areas including mountain grasslands, marshes, sand plains, seeps and streamsides. In the east the habitat narrows. Animal Diversity Web places the eastern subspecies where wild blue lupine grows, including sandy areas within oak savannas and pine barrens, and Wisconsin’s DNR records it in pine and oak barrens and sand barrens.
During the day males perch on hilltops to look for females, usually sitting on the ground or on low twigs. Females lay eggs singly under leaves of the host plants. The caterpillars feed on leaves and live in shelters of rolled or tied leaves, and fully grown caterpillars hibernate. Adults take flower nectar.
Caterpillar host plants
For the species overall, BAMONA names lupine (Lupinus), golden banner (Thermopsis), Lotus and other legumes. The eastern subspecies E. persius persius is dependent on wild blue lupine, Lupinus perennis, as its host, and Animal Diversity Web adds that it may also use wild indigo, Baptisia. The same page notes that earlier writing had suggested willow and poplar and that current research does not support those as host plants.
Flight season
BAMONA gives one brood, April to June. Wisconsin’s DNR is more precise for the Midwest: a single generation with a flight period from mid-May to early June, with larvae living and eventually hibernating in solitary nests on the plant and pupation the following spring.
Status: secure in the west, in trouble in the east
BAMONA gives a global rank of G4, apparently secure globally, though it might be quite rare in parts of its range. It also says populations in the Midwest and Northeast found in pine-oak barrens should be monitored and conserved. Wikipedia describes the eastern subspecies as rare and in severe decline, perhaps extirpated in Ontario, and lists legal protection as threatened in Michigan and endangered in Minnesota, Ohio, New York and New Hampshire. Animal Diversity Web names the causes: fire suppression that lets woodland close over lupine, loss of open savanna to development and agriculture, habitat fragmentation, and pesticide spraying against spongy moth in New England. Wisconsin carries it as a state special concern species.
What a gardener can and cannot do
This is the one butterfly of the four whose caterpillar plants are real garden plants. Lupine and wild indigo are plants a gardener can grow where soil and sun suit them. Whether a duskywing will find them is another matter, because the documented populations sit in open barrens and mountain grasslands, and none of the sources reports a garden planting that drew the species.
What the sources do support is management advice for lupine habitat: BAMONA recommends managing lupine-feeding populations by mechanical disturbance or infrequent burns, no more often than every five years. That is advice for land managers. For a yard the translation is limited to growing the host plant where it suits the soil, keeping the sun open and avoiding pesticides, which the sources name as a factor in the eastern decline. The butterfly garden guide covers sun, host plants and pesticide-free habit in general, and the rockslide checkerspot is a western neighbor whose caterpillars use sunflower-family plants.
A skipper that waits on bare ground for a mate and needs a plant that wants fire is not an easy neighbor for a tidy lawn.
Common questions
What is the Persius duskywing?
It is Erynnis persius, a small dark skipper in the family Hesperiidae. It ranges across much of western North America and in scattered eastern populations, and it is hard to tell from other duskywings. BAMONA notes that the Columbine, Wild Indigo and Persius duskywings belong to a confusing group of very similar butterflies called the Persius complex.
How do you identify a Persius duskywing?
The upperside is brown-black, with a few clear dots and very dim markings on the forewing and a grayish patch at the end of the cell. The male forewing has many raised white hairs and a costal fold holding yellow scent scales, and hindwing fringes are dark. The wingspan is 1 1/8 to 1 5/8 inches (2.9 to 4.2 cm).
What do Persius duskywing caterpillars eat?
Legumes. BAMONA lists lupine (Lupinus), golden banner (Thermopsis), Lotus and other legumes. In the East, the subspecies E. persius persius is dependent on wild blue lupine, Lupinus perennis, and Animal Diversity Web adds that it may also use wild indigo, Baptisia.
When do Persius duskywings fly?
There is one brood a year, flying April to June according to BAMONA. In Wisconsin, the DNR gives a flight period of mid-May to early June. Caterpillars live in shelters of rolled or tied leaves, and fully grown ones hibernate before pupating the next spring.
Is the Persius duskywing endangered?
The species as a whole is ranked apparently secure, but the eastern subspecies is in severe decline. Wikipedia lists it as endangered in Minnesota, Ohio, New York and New Hampshire and threatened in Michigan, and Wisconsin carries it as a state special concern species. Check current state lists before relying on this.
Can I grow plants for it?
Where lupine grows well and the butterfly occurs nearby, lupine is the documented caterpillar plant. The sources do not report garden plantings that drew it, so treat it as a plausible habitat step, not a promise. Pesticide spraying is among the documented causes of decline in the East.